Books like Second Sight

Second Sight by Jayne Ann Krentz reads as suspenseful, romantic. These 12 books share its genome — matched by how they actually read, not just their shelf label.

What Second Sight is like to read

A Victorian-set paranormal romance that pairs a resourceful heroine's reinvention with the reappearance of a lover she believed dead, braiding seduction, secret societies, and psychic bonding into a suspense plot. Best for: readers who want historical paranormal romance with a secret-society mystery and a reunion arc.

Homeport

Nora Roberts · 1998

A glamorous art-world suspense with a humiliated expert forced to trust a charming gallerist whose motives are suspect — the romance and the mystery escalate in tandem.

mildly eeriecomplete storydeep cut

Mischief

Jayne Ann Krentz · 1996

A spirited historical romance where a scheming heroine and a formidable explorer play at seduction as bait for a real villain, blending banter and danger.

guaranteed HEAmildly eeriecomplete story

Double Take

Catherine Coulter · 2007

A brisk romantic-suspense procedural: an attempted murder on a pier reopens a psychic's killing while a parallel Virginia missing-wife thread runs alongside.

deep cut

Safe Haven

Nicholas Sparks · 2010

A tender, intimate romance shadowed by genuine danger: Sparks' signature earnest voice carries both the fragile bloom of new love and the creeping dread of an unsafe past.

deep cut

Fifty Shades Darker

E. L. James · 2011

A breathless, first-person present-tense continuation of the Grey/Steele affair, heavy on explicit sex, jealous rivals, and Christian's tortured backstory drips.

happy-for-nowhigh heatmildly eerie

Immortal in Death

J.D. Robb · 1996

A procedural murder investigation that pulls Eve Dallas's personal life into the case when her best friend becomes prime suspect, set against a glossy fashion-world backdrop laced with designer drugs.

mildly eeriedeep cut

The Heiress Bride

Lynne Graham · 2002

A dramatic romance centered on two strong-willed characters navigating forced marriage, secrets, and passionate connection against a backdrop of wealth and Greek society.

deep cut

Are You Afraid of the Dark?

Sidney Sheldon · 2004

A high-octane conspiracy thriller in which two grieving widows become reluctant investigators, forced to evade a powerful organization while uncovering the truth behind their husbands' deaths.

deep cut

Poison Study

Maria V. Snyder · 2005

A propulsive palace-intrigue fantasy where a condemned prisoner turned food taster is kept on a leash of daily antidote — survival stakes braided with emerging magic and a slow-burn romance.

happy-for-nowmildly eeriedeep cut

Hush, hush

Becca Fitzpatrick · 2010

A high-school paranormal romance built on the pull toward a dangerous boy despite every warning — tension-forward, romance-driven, with supernatural menace flickering under the flirtation.

creepy, not goryYAcliffhanger

Open Season

Linda Howard · 2001

A librarian's deliberate reinvention spirals into danger when she witnesses a murder, forcing her to navigate a criminal investigation while discovering unexpected desire and agency.

complete storydeep cut